Skip to content
New Website!! Browse and let us know what you think

Account
Alice in Vintageland
Cart

Plush Stuffed Animals

Explore our collection of vintage plush stuffed animals! Find charming and nostalgic companions from yesteryears. Browse our curated selection of unique collectible toys, perfect for both play and display. Shop now and add a touch of whimsy to your collection.
Plush Stuffed Animals
Filters
Plush Stuffed Animals
Ty
Regular price $44.00 USD
Lot of 35 TY Beanie Babies, Pelican, Dragon, Monkey, Cat, Frog and More
Sold out
Regular price $24.00 USD
TY Beanie Babies Lot Of 2 Ghost Spooky and Spider Spinner Halloween
0
Regular price $49.90 USD
Lot of 9 Ty Bear Beanie Buddies w/tags *New Condition*
0
Regular price $27.90 USD
McDonalds Ty Teenie Beanies 1996 Full Set of 10 NIP Happy Meal Toys
0
Regular price $74.00 USD
Ty McDonalds Mini Teenie Beanie Babies FULL SETS - 1997 1998 & 1999 Plush Toys
0
Regular price $55.00 USD
Ty McDonalds Mini Teenie Beanie Babies 48 1998 & 1999 Plush Toys
0
Regular price $34.90 USD
Ty Beanie Babies Happy Meal 25th Anniv McDonalds 2004 Toys Full Set of 12
0
Regular price $34.90 USD
Ty Beanie Babies Happy Meal 25th Anniv McDonalds Full Set of 12 2004 Toys
0
Regular price $89.00 USD
23 TY Beanie Kids And Boppers Mixed Lot From 2000's / Beanie Babies Vintage
0
Regular price $8.00 USD Sale price $6.80 USD
Vintage TY The Original Beanie Babies Hippie, Bunny Rabbit Stuffed Animal w/Case
0
Regular price $19.00 USD Sale price $16.15 USD
Seaweed TY Beanie Baby w/tags
0
Regular price $12.99 USD Sale price $11.04 USD
TY The Original Beanie Baby, Pinky, Flamingo Stuffed Animal 6"
0
Regular price $25.10 USD Sale price $21.33 USD
Ty Beanie Babies - YIKES The Halloween 8"5' Bear Hallmark Exclusive VG
0
Regular price $20.40 USD Sale price $16.32 USD
Ty Beanie Buddies - CLOVER -The Bear 11" tall - St. Patricks Day 2002 EXCELLENT
0
Regular price $8.00 USD Sale price $6.40 USD
Vintage TY The Original Beanie Babies, Peace, Colorful Teddy Bear Stuffed Animal
0
Regular price $8.00 USD Sale price $6.80 USD
Vintage TY The Original Beanie Baby Tiptoe Mouse Plush with Tags , 6"
0
Regular price $12.99 USD Sale price $11.04 USD
Vintage TY The Original Beanie Baby Osito Mexican Teddy Bear Plush w Tags - 6"
0
Regular price $19.90 USD Sale price $17.91 USD
TY Beanie Buddy - PINCHERS the Lobster 14 inch 2001
0
Regular price $24.99 USD
Lot TY Beanie Babies lot of 9
0
Regular price $29.99 USD
Acrylic Display Cases lot of 9 Size: 8"x4"x4" made in USA
0
Regular price $14.00 USD Sale price $11.90 USD
Classic TY Beanie Babies- Rare, retired Jake the Duck 1997. (Errors on Tag)
0
Regular price $8.00 USD Sale price $6.40 USD
NM Vintage TY The Original Beanie Baby, Gracie, Swan Stuffed Animal
0
Regular price $8.00 USD Sale price $6.80 USD
NM Vintage TY The Original Beanie Babies, Halo, Angel Bear Stuffed Animal
0
Regular price $14.00 USD Sale price $12.60 USD
1999 Ty Pillow Pals Collection 🐶 WOOF the Dog Orange/Yellow
0
Regular price $31.40 USD Sale price $26.69 USD
CHOCOLATE the Moose TY BEANIE BABY 11" Tall , EXCELLENT
0